CJA Vol.32 Issue 3
Editorial: New Game, New Rules - p77
Mary Ann Chance and Rolf E. Peters
Response of Cervicobrachial Neuralgia to
Chiropractic Care - p78
Jason D. Lemon
EMG Response of the Human Frame to Wearing a
Backpack—A Review - p83
Andrew L. Vitiello and Henry Pollard
Backpack Design: The Use of Ratings of Perceived
Exertion ( Borg Scale) - A Review - p91
Andrew L. Vitiello and Henry Pollard
Did the SMT Practitioner Cause the Arterial Injury?
- p99
Allan G.J. Terrett
In Memoriam - Elmer L. Crowder - p111
ABSTRACTS
Response of Cervicobrachial Neuralgia to
Chiropractic Care
JASON D. LEMON
Objective: To present a case series of three patients presenting with
cervicobrachial neuralgia who were successfully treated with
chiropractic management. Clinical Features: Three patients suffering
from unilateral shoulder or arm pain and C7 nerve root compression are
described. Intervention and Outcome: All patients received postural
advice, cervical ROM stretches, deep massage to the cervicothoracic
spine, and chiropractic manipulation. All patients receiving
chiropractic care achieved a satisfactory resolution of their symptoms.
Conclusion: Chiropractic management, including manipulation, appears to
be a highly effective means of treating cervicobrachial neuralgia.
INDEX TERMS: CERVICOBRACHIAL NEURALGIA; CHIROPRACTIC; MANIPULATION;
INTERVERTEBRAL DISC HERNIATION; CERVICAL RADICULOPATHY.
Back to top
EMG Response of the Human Frame to Wearing a
Backpack-A Review
ANDREW L. VITIELLO and HENRY POLLARD
Objective: To review current scientific knowledge pertaining to
backpacks and various other modalities employed to carry loads. A second
objective of this paper is to comment on current methods of assessing
the effects of load and carriage on the human body. The reviewers have
contrasted the potential benefits of surface electromyography (s-EMG)
over metabolic assessment measures in preparing this review. Data
Sources: The current scientific literature was examined using the
MEDLINE® database and was accessed using the PUBMED® online search
engine. The MANTIS® database was also searched for additional material.
Study Selection: Sixty-three journal articles were chosen from a
selection of 104. Of these, 38 that pertained to the aims of this
discussion were included. Data Extraction: The journals were selected
based on relevance to the topic discussed, i.e. results pertaining to
EMG, metabolic measurement approaches, assessment of different load
carriage methods, load placements on the spine as well as effects loads
have on the spine, gait or general biomechanics of the human frame. Data
Synthesis: From the literature, we find that EMG is a valid but poorly
utilised tool in assessing the effects of load on the human frame. There
is yet little evidence to suggest a clear rationale behind the
determination of an ideal backpack weight that can be used as a
guideline for advising wearers. Conclusion: Ideal load placement on the
human frame requires further and more detailed study. The relationship
between the level of perceived exertion and the EMG trace still requires
further large-study investigation. The literature supports the notion
that Mean Power Frequency (MPF) analysis can be used as a reliable and
repeatable method of determining fatigue in smaller muscle groups. Its
use should be favoured against more global and less specific metabolic
measures. Observations in both children and adolescents have found that
painful syndromes may occur because of overloaded backpacks.
Longitudinal observations are needed to confirm a causative link between
these loaded states and painful syndromes.
INDEX TERMS: (MeSH): LOAD; ELECTROMYOGRAPHY; WEIGHT BEARING; (OTHER):
BACKPACKS; SCHOOL CHILDREN.
Back to top
Backpack Design: The Use of Ratings of
Perceived Exertion (Borg Scale)-A Review
ANDREW L. VITIELLO and HENRY POLLARD
Objective: To consider the design features of backpacks in light of
current scientific knowledge. Particular focus is drawn to the methods
used to assess the benefits of assisted load carrying. The second
objective is to discuss the increasingly dated knowledge regarding
clinical use of surface EMG (s-EMG) and Ratings of Perceived Exertion
(RPE) as valid tools in the assessment. Data Sources: The current
scientific literature was examined using the MEDLINE® database and was
accessed using the PUBMED® online search engine. The MANTIS® database
was also searched for additional material. Study Selection: Forty-six
journal articles were chosen from a selection of 104 that had satisfied
the online search criteria and pertained to the aims of this discussion.
Data Extraction: Journal articles were included based on relevance to
the topics discussed. Selected articles had particular results
pertaining to either electromyography (EMG), RPE assessment of different
load carriage methods, load placements on the spine and the effects
loads have on the spine and gait. Data Synthesis: From the literature,
we find that s-EMG is a valid tool for use in clinical assessment of
muscular effects of load on the human frame. We have found that more
extensive trials need to be performed, using larger sample sizes,
matched groups and extensive sampling points in order that s-EMG can be
readily utilised by the wider scientific community for such analyses.
Conclusion: It is apparent that placement of a load as close as possible
to the centre of mass of the body is important, especially when
considering these concepts to relate the weight carried to fatigue, as
well as to specific bag design features. There is evidence to suggest
that in the adult population fatigue can be reduced if loads are kept as
close as possible to 30% of the wearer’s lean body mass, while the 10%
maximum load for children is a figure that requires further exploration
in order to justify completely. The literature supports use of a
combination of both s-EMG and Borg scales (RPEs) as acceptable, valid,
repeatable measures to test the body’s responses to loads using
different backpack designs.
INDEX TERMS: (MeSH): LOAD; ELECTROMYOGRAPHY; WEIGHT BEARING; (OTHER):
BACKPACKS; SCHOOL CHILDREN.
Back to top
Did the SMT Practitioner Cause the Arterial
Injury?
ALLAN G.J. TERRETT
The close temporal relationship between cervical spinal manipulation
therapy (SMT) and the development of brain, brainstem and/or ischaemic
incidents suggests a cause-and-effect relationship. This conclusion is
strengthened by anatomical, biomechanical and pathologically plausible
mechanisms to account for the onset of central nervous system symptoms
and signs, and may incorrectly lead investigators (medical, insurance,
legal and press) to the conclusion of an obvious cause-and-effect
relationship. Other mechanisms for identical outcomes are investigated
in this paper.
INDEX TERMS: (MeSH): VERTEBRAL ARTERY; CHIROPRACTIC; OSTEOPATHIC
MEDICINE; PHYSICAL THERAPY; MALPRACTICE; RISK MANAGEMENT; CERVICAL
VERTEBRAE; CEREBROVASCULAR DISORDERS; WALLENBERG’S SYNDROME;
QUADRIPLEGIA; ADVERSE EFFECTS;; IATROGENIC DISEASE; (OTHER): ARTERIAL
DISSECTION.
Back to top
|