CJA Vol.28 Issue 2
Editorial: Research and the State of the Art
Mary Ann Chance and Rolf E. Peters
The Canadian Genealogy of Daniel David Palmer: An Update
Herbert J. Vear
American and Australian Chiropractic Practice: A
Comparative Study
Jennifer R. Jamison
The Culture of Chiropractic: An Educational
Perspective
Andries M. Kleynhans
Commentary: Identifying Non-specific Wellness
Triggers in Chiropractic Care
Jennifer R. Jamison
Report from the Eighth Annual the Meeting of the Chiropractic
Research Journal Editors' Council
Chiropractic Research Journal Editors' Council
In Memoriam: Irene Lillian Evans, Alan Plint, Kenneth Lindsay
Morgan
Book Review - Abstracts - Briefly
American and Australian Chiropractic
Practice: A Comparative Case Study
JENNIFER R. JAMISON
A small case study of American chiropractors and their patients was
undertaken to compare the chiropractic practice behaviours of
chiropractors practising on the west coast of North America and
Australia. Research Design.. A case study of nine American chiropractors
was undertaken. Data was collected by interviewing five Californian and
four Oregon practitioners and analysing completed questionnaires from 25
of their patients. Purposive sampling of practitioners was undertaken
using a maximum variation strategy. Convenience sampling of patients was
performed within five participating practices. Thematic analysis of the
interviews was correlated with information derived from the patient
questionnaires. This data was compared with a similar study undertaken
involving 25 Australian chiropractors and 124 of their patients.
Results. Despite apparent discrepancies in the patient sample between
the two studies, the similarities between American and Australian
chiropractic practice seem greater than the differences. Two differences
to emerge were, however the increased emphasis by American
chiropractors on active patient participation and the use of written
informed consent, particularly by the Californian chiropractors in this
study. Conclusion: While generalization is difficult given the size and
distribution of the American sample! this preliminary study suggests
substantial similarities in chiropractic behaviours which transcends
cultural differences.
INDEX TERMS: CHIROPRACTIC; INFORMED CONSENT; PATIENT
PARTICIPATION.
Chiropr J Aust 1998; 28:43-8.
Back to top
The Culture of Chiropractic: An Educational
Perspective
ANDRIES M. KLEYNHANS
Evidence is provided that chiropractors are a cultural group with
distinctive characteristics which impact greatly on their education. The
culture of chiropractic is defined and explored in the context of
education and change, plurality, symbolism and work of a chiropractor.
The development of a chiropractic culture is explicated in terms of the
controls exerted and resource allocation to the chiropractic curricula
and the structural setting of chiropractic education, the ideological
and cultural setting in which chiropractic exists and the curricular
dimensions of the sociological and cultural foundations of
chiropractic.
INDEX TERMS: MeSH: AUSTRALIA; CHIROPRACTIC; CULTURE; SOCIOCULTURAL
FACTORS; EDUCATION; CURRICULUM. OTHER: RMIT UNIVERSITY.
Chiropr J Aust 1998;28:49-64.
Back to top
Commentary: Identifying Non-specific Wellness
Triggers in Chiropractic Care
JENNIFER R. JAMISON
The relationship between conventional and complementary medicine is
emerging as a challenging health care issue. In the United Kingdom,
interest in this area has resulted in working groups having been set up
to consider both the current positions of orthodox, complementary and
alternative medicine and to explore how far it would be appropriate and
possible for these groups to work more closely together.' Professions
and therapies being explored in this investigation include chiropractic,
osteopathy, acupuncture, homoeopathy, nutritional, herbal and mind-body
medicine. The timeliness of such an endeavour relates both to the
increasing community interest in such a pursuit and the emerging
paradigm shaft in medical thinking. The biomedical/biomechanical model
of determinism, reductionism and dualism is being replaced by the
infomedical model characterized by internationalism, holism and monism.
The unilinear causality of determinism within the reductionist
biomechanical model is being superseded by the cybernetic circularity of
mutual causality in an interactive infomedical model. Such changes in
thinking promise to transform the face of health care in the twenty-
first century.
Chiropr J Aust 1998;28:65-9.
Back to top
|